White, Blue and Gold: An Analysis of the Religious Ideals in the Director's Cut of Kingdom of Heaven
Over the years religion has been a prime
topic of conversation in cinema. One of
the most common discourses deals with the differences between the Muslim and
Christian faiths. These discussions, though prevalent mostly try to maintain a
neutral viewpoint when it comes to the moral correctness of either religion. Though
these attempts to remain unbiased are admirable I will offer a different solution
granted by the themes and motifs present in Ridley Scott's Director's Cut of Kingdom of Heaven .
At
first glance the film seems to be the obvious choice for such an exploration. Though,
as the analysis continues one discovers that film has far more to say about
religion in cinema than just being a call for religious neutrality. In fact, it
is one of Kingdom of Heaven's
greatest strength that it remains steadfast on its positions, and does not lose
focus on trying to appease different parties at once. Now, that does not mean
that one religious ideal is more dominant than the other, but instead that both ideals are separate from one
another.
People may argue that this in fact his
balance, I would suggest that Scott clearly separates the Muslim and Christian
ideals into their own distinct storylines, which in turn allows both of the
belief systems to be explored to a fuller extent. In remaining bias Scott is
able to conclude each of the two storylines separately without compromising.
Kingdom
of Heaven is a film dominated by the idea of separation, and
perhaps one of the most interesting uses of this idea is in the color scheme. The
color scheme throughout the film, in a way allows for the idea of separate storylines. Each religion has its own
distinctive colors, gold and black for the Moslems, and red, white and blue for
the Christians. Interestingly though, Christianity's three colors do not
represent a singular belief system, but instead different variations on the
system. Rad, represents the Templars, the perversion of Catholicism, white, the
true nature of Catholicism and Christianity and blue the loss of faith. All are
expressed through the dominant colors in both the set and costume design.
This color palate dominates the majority
of the film. Though there still remains one distinct use of none color.
Jerusalem, this location is neither Muslim nor Christian and it is presented as
such. The city gravitates more towards neutral colors instead favoring any reds,
blues or golds. Jerusalem is a "Kingdom of conscience, a Kingdom of
Heaven." As Lord Godfrey states as he lay dying. Therefore, Jerusalem
belongs to God .
This neutral color scheme is present at the film's opening to illustrate
this idea even further, as Balian dreams of his dead wife. The dream is awash
in natural color, again favoring none of the other dominant tones. The audience
is then taken out of the dream by the following line. "Come on this is not
Heaven, it is a world and there are troubles in it." This scene indicates
that there is a clear separation between the places of God and the places Man.
As Balian is brought out of his reverie in
these opening moments the audience is made aware of the fact that the
"World" is saturated in a bluish tint. This suggests that people are not the only ones who lose their faith, but entire country do as
well. In fact, the blue tint does not start to subside until Balian begins his
journey to the Holy Land, on which the color is continually deemphasized until
the color design comes to rest on the neutral tones of Jerusalem.
In terms of the color scheme Balian is
interesting character to examine because he constantly switches his religious
affiliation to suit the situation at hand, though these continual switches may be
construed as an attempt to create an unbiased character. In the end Balian does
indeed determines his religious affiliation; I suggest that this consistent
changing allows for a greater understanding of each ideology, not to represent
his unbiased nature, but to ultimately allow him to come to a decision. Again, both the Muslim
and Christian faith have their own distinct storylines in the film which are
not reliant on one another to succeed.
This idea is brought to the forefront in
the film's conclusion as Balian hands over control of Jerusalem to the Muslims.
As the dénouement begins Saladin walks through the abandoned city, which continues to change its allegiances as he examines the fallen city. One of the
most interesting moments in this sequence is when Saladin picks up a fallen
cross and puts back in its proper place. Though this action suggests that the
Muslims have a reverence for the Catholic faith, it also indicates that the
Muslims are indeed victorious in this instance because the cross is made of
solid gold.
Religious iconography is a large
component of Kingdom of Heaven,
giving the color scheme yet other vessels in which to explore the various
religious ideals. Ironically though, the only religious symbol present in the
film is the cross. Even though this is the case it is used in a variety of ways
to express the many religions present. One such usage comes at the opening of the film. The film
begins with a shot of a crossroads completely saturated in a blue tint. In
fact, the scene is so saturated that the actual cross component of the
crossroads is nothing but a silhouette. This is a further indication that
Europe as a whole has no true faith.Though there is still Balian who is seeking
his own understanding of religion. In this regard symbols play another
important role. In Balian’s residence near Jerusalem there are a series of
white skeleton images, above which Balian reads. "As we are so you will
be.” Though this phrase speaks of death, it also indicates Balian’s ultimate
desire of becoming a true Christian.
In
the film's final scenes the idea of the two separate religious storylines come to
fruition, as the Muslims are victorious in Jerusalem and Balian returns home to
England with a truer understanding of Christianity. With Balian’s return home,
the English landscape sees the disappearance of the blue tint, and more of a
reliance on natural pure color. This change suggests that true Christianity is
represented by pure natural colors. In emphasis of this the film concludes with
a shot of the crossroads. However, the cross is now clearly defined and given
its natural colors.
Kingdom of Heaven is
one of those rare films that does not attempt to be unbiased towards certain
faith systems, but instead attempts to
present faith in the truest possible way.
As result the film is strengthened because it not only is able to discuss
religion as a component of cinema, but also illustrate how religions can be
presented on film without any particular compromise.
Comments
Post a Comment